I haved used both of these lubes on my 1911's and haven't had a problem with either one.
My question is (for either one), how long after applying these lubes can you wait before needing to reapply ? If the gun is left in storage for a month or two, should it be relubed prior to shooting, or will it be "good to go" as is?
If the lube is still visible on the weapon, you are good to go. I've gone over a month with a carrygun, and my closet guns haven't been touched in probably three months or so.
Both FP-10 and Protec/Wilson Ultima-Lube will offer lubrication even when there isn't a "wet" surface, but protection from corrosion is more of a concern which is why I recommend a visible thin film on all metal parts.
Like Clay,I always leave a visible film of oil on the weapons,inside and out,for storage.They are wiped down with FP-10 immediately after they are handled or carried as well.
I always check my firearms that are in storage every month and relube every three months or as needed.
So far the FP-10 has not needed much attention or relubing which has extended my service intervals somewhat.Which is good because it takes me about five hours to go over my collection.
The FP-10 seems to stick around for a long time without running off or drying out.
I cant say anything about the Wilson or Protec lubes since I have had no experience with them.
I would stick with the FP-10.It works.
HTH
Raymond
I don't have yet tested FP-10 "new formula", but I use often Wilson Ultima Lube and I can speak well about it. It seems exceptionally similar to Militec-1 in odor, color and density, but it has much better anticorrosion properties, altough not on par with the very best products. regards, Maxm
Speaking about anticorrosion properties, BreakFree CLP old formula (I didn't test the new), CorrosionX, CRC GunStor for oils;
RIG, Militec-1 and some others for greases. I have yet to try FP-10 new formula, I ordered yesterday a bottle.
Regards, MAXM
Don't get too wraped-up in these lube questions. My two cents is they'rwe all about the same. I always place a drop or two on the rails before shooting after takeing it out of storage. I like Remington oil myself.
Rimfire, 22, sometimes also I think that oil choice isn't so important, but then I run my comparative tests and see very different results, and remember a beautiful Walther .22 match rifle I rusted many years ago by choosing a bad oil...
Have a nice day, MAXM
I like to use CLP to clean, lube, and protect. I wipe it down, then I spray a generous amount of Remingtopn dry lube.....which leans a coating that does not dissipate....perfect for long term storage.
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
1911Forum
7.6M posts
204.2K members
Since 2000
A forum community dedicated to all 1911 firearm owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!