Never. Republicans (the party that is slightly better on the 2nd amendment) had the presidency, the senate, and the House and did nothing but bloat the fed even more.So when are we going to stop these out of control, illegal, criminal agencies? It is every Americans born right to own a machine gun. Who made the ATF ghod?
Perhaps - but that expost facto prohibition probably wouldn't stop them from confiscating them.I think the ex-post facto prohibition in the constitution would prevent the BATFE from making criminals of the owners, if they have the proper stamp and paper work that was approved by the BATFE.
There are many legal hurdles here that would make it impossible to convict someone owning one that dotted all the 'i's and crossed all the 't's.
Still, it could put a cloud on continued ownership of those weapons.
I think the ex-post facto prohibition in the constitution would prevent the BATFE from making criminals of the owners, if they have the proper stamp and paper work that was approved by the BATFE.
There are many legal hurdles here that would make it impossible to convict someone owning one that dotted all the 'i's and crossed all the 't's.
Still, it could put a cloud on continued ownership of those weapons.
Requiring someone to surrender something that WAS perfectly legal for the past 29 years all because some bureaucrat arbitrarilly changed their mind, ammounts to a 5th amendment violation. (depriving of property without due process.)Perhaps - but that expost facto prohibition probably wouldn't stop them from confiscating them.
Sadly, no. The 5th just guarantees due process; not fair process or, more importantly, fair process-ors ... another reason I REALLY hope we see a 3rd Party soon, as it seems the only way to avoid armed conflict.Requiring someone to surrender something that WAS perfectly legal for the past 29 years all because some bureaucrat arbitrarilly changed their mind, ammounts to a 5th amendment violation. (depriving of property without due process.)
For all the "come and take it" and bravado about F the BATFE, very few are going to fire a shot if it came to that. The same group toes the line and plays by the rules, offers up no real resistance. Step one would be civil disobedience. I recently asked the question about an NFA item Form 20, some one was having a meltdown about approval times from BATFE. I asked when was the last time you saw, EVER saw, some ATF guys at a range doing some sort of "check"?So when are we going to stop these out of control, illegal, criminal agencies? It is every Americans born right to own a machine gun. Who made the ATF ghod?
"Due process" does not include making something illegal, (ex-post facto even!), by fiat of a unelected bureaucrat.Sadly, no. The 5th just guarantees due process; not fair process or, more importantly, fair process-ors ... another reason I REALLY hope we see a 3rd Party soon, as it seems the only way to avoid armed conflict.
I *think* this is simply enforcing an existing law (products not registered by a cutoff date). I agree it would be (kinda) like confiscating a classic car for lack of seat belts, but if there is no statute of limitation, it will likely be unsuccessfully challenged."Due process" does not include making something illegal, (ex-post facto even!), by fiat of a unelected bureaucrat.
I doubt there was a rush to make a lot of M2 carbines on the last day.It figures. Right when I am on the verge of having enough "disposable income" to buy an M2 carbine.
That is exactly what it is... an arbitrary decision not based on the LAW...Requiring someone to surrender something that WAS perfectly legal for the past 29 years all because some bureaucrat arbitrarilly changed their mind, ammounts to a 5th amendment violation. (depriving of property without due process.)
I have 4 NFA guns and getting ready to buy a suppressorI wonder what percent of legal gun owners also have a stamp for an automatic weapon. I would guess, the suppressor stamp has more of a following as while the stamp price is the same the unit price point is "extremely" lower. So the idea here is the government like the wolf is cutting out the smallest member of the herd - to gnaw on.
Anyone have any national numbers? I found some sketchy stuff on VA but that was it. http://hamptonroads.com/2012/10/virginia-tops-us-machine-gun-owners