1911Forum banner

1 - 20 of 50 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
304 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Can somebody please tell me why it is bad for a slide to be released on an empty mag? I have always heard that this was bad for a pistol, but nobody seems to be able to give me much of a reason for it. Thanks
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
356 Posts
If you mean on an empty chamber then I can give you a reason. From what I understand the extractor can impact the rim of the barrel and if done enough times can break the extractor. I have heard it can also adversly effect your trigger pull. A few times will not hurt but I would not make it a habit. Hope that helps :]

------------------
Men sleep safe in there beds at night because rough men stand ready to do violence on their behalf.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,157 Posts
To add further, when the slide comes forward on a round, stripping it from the mag, it is "controlled" by the drag of the round being stripped, and chambered. It "cushions" the impact of the slide closing.

This also provide some support to the extractor tip, so it's not likely to be damaged.

Also, with guns that have had Trigger Work done, it prevents the sear/disconnector from taking a beating. The impact creates harmonics that could cause sear bounce. This can be terminal for maintaining a nice crisp, glass like trigger in a gun that's had an excellent trigger done.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
304 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
ah I see what you mean. Does the act of stripping a round really provide that much "cushion"?
Wouldn't the round be behind the extractor? Wouldn't this still cause it to come to rest in the same position as without a round in the chamber?
thanks again guys
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,157 Posts
Not exactly sure what either ahenry or 225 is trying to say...

The movement of the slide does "slow", although not perceptibly to you or I when a round is picked up from the mag. You should never close the slide on an empty chamber, or on a round that has been hand chambered.

Damage can result from repeated use.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
87 Posts
Haven't heard that one before, even the one about dry firing with no round in the chamber, we do both, a lot every day, and haven't seen an extractor break or a firing pin break. I am not saying it can never happen, but we put the guns thru a lot before they are fired and don't see what you are talking about...

mark
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
347 Posts
This is a good topic, and I've been wondering about it myself. I just bought a 1991A1, and the factory owner's manual says to release the slide on an empty chamber as part of a function check after re-assembly.

I can find the page number if anyone wants to go and look it up.

------------------
I wonder why we waste our lives here,
when we could run away to paradise.

But I am caught in some invisible vice
and I can't get away.

To live and die in L.A.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
304 Posts
Discussion Starter #9
Thanks for the "colt" answer mark. I have heard that letting the slide slam home on an empty chamber (no round in the mag) it can damage it. I could never really figure out why so I thought I would ask the "panal of experts" *grin* Nice to know that it really doesn't matter
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
131 Posts
This may well be one of those Questions With No Answer. I am not aware of any danger to the extractor from this practice, though another practice, single loading by placing a round directly in the chamber and slamming the slide on it, will definitely be very rough on the extractor.

As for the sear/hammer engagement surfaces, they will be subjected to far greater shock if the slide is allowed to run forward without chambering a round. The side is quite appreciably slowed by stripping and chambering a round, as another poster mentioned. The heavier the slide, and the stronger the recoil spring, the harder the hit. There is a reason Colt suggests this as a function check. The hammer will bounce on impact, and if the hammer/sear engagement surfaces are worn, the hammer may fall to half cock. On a GI spec trigger job, this test shouldn't hurt anything, but don't expect a shooter with a nice 2 lb. IPSC trigger job not to cringe when you do that to his or her gun.

Of course this is all my opinion. If you do have a nifty trigger job, check with your smith on proper handling procedures.

-MD
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
267 Posts
Springfield recommends that you NOT do it. I did, before I read the booklet, which is just like a guy, and felt stupid.
I don't use maps or ask directions, either.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
5,388 Posts
Can somebody please tell me why it is bad for a slide to be released on an empty mag? I have always heard that this was bad for a pistol, but nobody seems to be able to give me much of a reason for it. Thanks
Yah, thats no good!

V/R
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,266 Posts
This topic will show a real difference of opinion on this.
My belief is that generally it is not good practice to repeatedly drop the slide on an empty chamber, particularly on 1911's. Abuse of the sear & wear on the slide stop are excelerated. Other pistol designs may not be as vulnerable, but in general I personally frown on the practice.
That being said...
Occasionally for function testing or in competition post stage unload & show clear is fine IMHO.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
15,504 Posts
But the 'slam' is a valid test for hammer follow and I do it on a function check. Obviously I completely understand the mechanical and aesthetic reasons for not letting the slide slam without loading and I don't do this often.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
94 Posts
Disclaimer: I'm not a gunsmith, I have no exceptional knowledge apart from reading books, instructional materials online & experience striping, cleaning,replacing parts & doing my own trigger jobs on other platforms (not 1911).

I've racked the slide hundreds of times & practiced dry firing, loaded a round manually & released the slide to battery prior to inserting a full magazine & fired thousands of rounds through my Glock 23, S&W Shield, Desert Eagle Pistol 9mm (early baby eagle) with no appreciable negative effects that I can see when I completely strip the guns. This may be bad practice, I just haven't/can't see the negative effects.

If I'm correct (& I already acknowledg I may be completely wrong, see disclaimer), and there are no appreciable negative effects on these other platforms, what is different, & dare I say, so much more delicate about a 1911 that this platform can't handle these practices?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
23,189 Posts
Some of it is gun etiquette. If it is your gun then whatever. It is yours. If a friend shows you his and I will us a 1911 as an example as we on this forum then I would not "drop the slide". Maybe you could if you asked him/her first, but I generally would not. You also ask if it is O.K. to dry fire it or pull the trigger on an empty chamber. Don't do this and you will be labeled a jerk and not invited back most of the time. Also treat your gun very well when showing it to others for obvious reasons.

When I go out and shoot with somebody I sort of know but have not shot with before I take along RIAs and Ruger SR1911s in 1911 land. Maybe I will shoot with them again and maybe not. A time to meet new friends and forge new relationships. I still have one jerk that calls me and asks me when do we want to go shooting again. I think 3014 might be a nice year.
 
1 - 20 of 50 Posts
Top