Nathan , Boy your putting me on the spot here since I build both for the company and have carried both . I carry the Rafter S Avenger style myself out of personal reasons . But I also wore the Lo-Profile for years to before we developed the Avenger Rafter S style . The Lo-Pro is thinner and conceals very well and has a Thumb safety gaurd which also keeps the sweat off your peice , very nice holster . The Rafter S is straight comp/carry bred holster that also conceals well is of a time proven design carried for years by several knowledgable pistoleros . In my opinion the Wilson is comfy for carry and so is the Rafter S , but I like the Rafter S better for its style and for actual range use . In the end only you can decide my son which is right for you . Since I get to work if you buy either one I wont try to sell you one over the other I will only give you my honest advice . or you could do as I did and buy them both , after all I use four different holsters for different occasions . If you really want a comfy IWB you need to get a Wilson Covert Companion while we still make the old style , I carry for 12-16 hours at a time with ultimate comfort . They are going to a new style which in my opinion is a mistake , but I dont make the rules I just build the Holsters for the Bosses . Good Luck .