1911Forum banner
Status
Not open for further replies.

Carry Conditions? 1-2-3-4

4.3K views 39 replies 25 participants last post by  Kevin Rohrer  
#1 · (Edited)
Have I lost my mind or am I dealing with morons or am I just getting old and grouchy?

I got into a "tiff" with the CCWSafe people over Condition Two carry.

They had some good looking guy with a tactical beard I've never heard of who is a Tier 1 "Operator" (so he must be an exspurt) who wrote an article related to the recent video of the shopkeeper and son who were killed because he carried in Cond 3 and while fumbling to rack the slide he either didn't load or caused a double feed malfunction.

OK - Their article called Condition 1 (round in chamber or locked and loaded) correctly - but they called Condition 2 "mag in, no round in chamber."

I corrected them that is Condition THREE.

With Condition TWO being "round in chamber, hammer down, decocked and/or safety on." We all know this is the appropriate way to carry a DA/SA, but may be considered unsafe for a 1911 or SA only, due to the rare possibility of an unintended firing.

So I pointed this out to them. Their response was that for "their purposes" of the article Cond 1 was loaded and Cond 2 was empty chamber.

I basically said - "sorry you don't get to change the rules" and you are going to confuse inexperienced readers with your Cond 2 and everyone else's Cond 3. (I was a little less delicate in my words though...) So they said, "Well times have changed and the rules were for 1911's and while they were "fans" of Cooper (nut never met him) that "new technology" requires new terms. ***???

So I replied, "Well Jeff Cooper personally taught me how to shoot 1911's 35 years ago" and the new technology hasn't changed the fundamentals.

So am I missing something? Did the rules change and I missed it.

Cond 0 - round chambered, mag in, hammer cocked, safety off.

Cond 1 - round chambered, mag in, hammer cocked, safety on. Preferred cond for SA autos, acceptable for DA/SA autos without decocker.

Cond 2 - round chambered, mag in, hammer down, safety on. Preferred method for DAO or DA/SA with decocker.

Cond 3 - chamber empty, mag in, hammer down, safety on. Must be racked before firing. Not usually a good idea for a defense gun - appropriate for hunting.

Cond 4 - gun empty.
 
Discussion starter · #4 ·
Thanks - I know I'm right. I am ALWAYS right, even when I'm wrong. A benefit of being both old and still alive after a long and nefarious life. But the youngsters think they know better. :D :D

OMG - they are STILL arguing with me on FB over this. I suggested that they ask Larry Vickers since he promotes their legal services.

Thinking of posting a link to the Beards McOperator video - but I guess that would be just plain cruel. :)
 
Discussion starter · #38 ·
Let's don't hoke it up and stretch terminology out of shape. Cooper Conditions of readiness truly apply only to single action autos like 1911 and BHP.

Cond 0 - round chambered, mag in, hammer cocked, safety off.

Cooper referred to a super squirrel agency that carried BHPs safety off, but I do not recall him calling that "Condition Zero." He did not use the term "Condition Black" for Engaging in Combat, either.

Cond 1 - round chambered, mag in, hammer cocked, safety on. Preferred cond for SA autos, acceptable for DA/SA autos without decocker.

For a "Selective DA" auto like CZ75 for which we may forget about the DA altogether and treat it like a normal pistol.

Cond 2 - round chambered, mag in, hammer down, safety on. Preferred method for DAO or DA/SA with decocker.

Usual, yes, but not in the Cooper lexicon.

Cond 3 - chamber empty, mag in, hammer down, safety on. Must be racked before firing. Not usually a good idea for a defense gun - appropriate for hunting.

Not even possible with 1911 or BHP. I understand some Spanish pistols, some CZ copies, and post Cooper designs from SIG et al. can apply the safety with the hammer down. As well as Walther based DA/SA which were generally beneath Cooper's notice.

Cond 4 - gun empty,

I just don't think Cooper bothered to assign a number to an empty gun.


Jan Stevenson once did a series of humor pieces in which he assigned numbers to physically possible but senseless conditions of (non) readiness.
He had it carefully planned out to conclude:
Magazine loaded, chamber empty, decocked, safety on; in a flap holster with the flap bucked down.
Condition 13.
It might be funny except that was the actual carry condition of the West German police for their .32 Walther PPs in the pre- Red Army Brigade and Baader Meinhoff Gang era.
And although I am not admitting to any failings or misidentifying of my condition memory - you are right. I think we added the other "conditions" over the years. Kind of like "black," which really should be color code, "Duck!". ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.