1911Forum banner

Hornady temporarily suspends nickel-plated brass cases for Critical Defense

1 reading
9.6K views 28 replies 18 participants last post by  Nitro.45  
#1 ·
#4 ·
It sort of reminds me of the emperor's new clothes.
 
#7 ·
You can reload them, the issue is that they don't last as long (as many reloads) as plain brass. After a a number of times (depending on charge) they will crack - either at the mouth or along the length - earlier than the plain brass. I had a bunch in .45 Colt from back in the early '90s. Nearly all finally gave up the ghost. The brass ones have lasted much longer.
 
#19 ·
I have a stash of 9mm 115 Critical defense for the sig, and a stash of .45 Winchester White Box 230 jhp for the 1911.

For target / shtf scenarios, I have plenty of ball. I'm not going to waste SD ammo on paper* or shtf. I must have 5x in ball than I do in jhp.

*JHP on paper: For me occasionally, to see if the guns still like to feed it, and I can still hit with it

I posted the original link simply to show that transportation-tier issues are hurting everyone, not just lumber. This also tells me Hornady isnt plating their own shells, they're having someone else do it.

Both my SD loads show up in ammoseek from time to time - at prices far more ridiculous than the already-inflated pre-rona prices. Boy howdy Hornady is proud of this ammo! I think i was paying 80¢/rd for these before 'rona.
 
#20 ·
From experience making custom Harley springer front ends out of 4140 and having them chromed, Hydrogen Embrittelment is most likey the cause of nickel plated cases cracking early on. Even with proper heat treating of the brass cases, plated cases just do not last very long, especially at the crimp area.

Considering that most of us shoot FMJ in brass cases for range/practice and save the spendy stuff for carry, we really don't amass much in the way of plated cases, at least I don't, and that's a good thing.
 
#24 ·
Same here flechero. We need to start cleaning cases so we can reload the .223 ammo shot over the last three weeks of prairie doggin'. Actually, the reloading is mostly done during the winter months; the vibrator runs anytime.
 
  • Like
Reactions: flechero
#28 ·
I hear ya, but I'd rather remind than rub-in. Because the drought gets worse each time around.

The ammo shortage was soft but expensive during the economic panic in 2008-2009. Then it got better.

The ammo shortage intensified in 2013 after Sandy Hook. Then after a year or year-and-a-half, it got much better for a very long time, especially after Trump was elected. For a year or two, they couldn't hardly give ammo away, regardless of commodity inflation.

Then in 2020, Covid, social unrest, and the election all hit at once. Everyone that didn't have a gun went out and bought one. And then they realized they didn't have enough ammo.

This is the worst ammo shortage and pricing environment I've ever seen or heard of, but it's getting better. If there is a demand, capitalism will supply it. It's just gonna take a while and cost a little more going forward. I see ammo for sale now that I haven't seen in over a year, but I still wouldn't pay these prices if I didn't have to.

I hope the new gun owners won't forget this era because they were the primary cause of the shortages. And when things do get back to normalish, buy a little at a time so that you don't have to freak out like all the folks that simultaneously shat their pants and all the sudden couldn't find enough TP :)